Easy to Use, Lasting Brows
This is my first time using the refills as my original pencil finally gave out. I noticed there was a white cast around the outside pencil but it still did apply normally. Taking a star off for that, hoping it isn’t an expiration date issue. As for the refills itself, it was easy to pop back in and use immediately. I do love the natural coverage this gives, and it lasts throughout the day.
Thanks for your review of the Plume refills. We checked in with Plume and the white cast is totally normal, it's just a bit of oxidation on the surface. It wipes off and has no effect on the use/function of the pencil. We order from Plume every month with this product being a best seller so we can confirm the batch received would be the freshest on hand. If you are not satisfied with the product though we are happy to get a replacement out to you. Feel free to reach out to us at email@example.com.